It is hard for me to review either of the band's albums (2007's Touch Up and 2008's O My Heart) without falling into the trap of gushing like a schoolgirl without making any real objective critique. This is because after a lot (and I mean a lot) of repeat listens to both, I am still amazed by their quality, as well as the fact that no-one in my country seems to have heard of them. Instead of even trying to do a proper review, I will instead try to justify why I like them so much.
I first discovered Mother Mother upon hearing one of their more well-known singles, a track called Ghosting. It was love at first listen. The song opens with a few gentle string riffs, before moving onto an acoustic guitar melody and the sweetly understated voice of Ryan Guldemond. The insightfully poetic lyrics are probably what got me hooked so quickly. Guldemond compares himself to a homeless ghost haunting the object of his affections. The song continues as a gentle acoustic number, building to a climax as the singer makes somewhat unnerving ghostly promises over a slightly heavier string-fueled backdrop. The song then segues beautifully from this section to the stripped back conclusion where the protagonist of the song reveals that he has decided to leave the situation alone.
"And this is why I have decided
To pull these old white sheets from my head
I'll leave them folded neat and tidy
So that you'll know I'm out of hiding"
Even though I have listened to this song more than 70 times according to iTunes (I would call this a conservative estimate) I still can't listen to it without sighing wistfully.
From there, I got my hands on both of their albums. Often when I look into an artist because of an individual song, I find myself disappointed. In this case, I found myself a new favourite band.
Touch Up is extremely impressive for a debut album. Consider the fact that it was released only 2 years after the band first started playing together and it is even more impressive. What I love the most about the songs on this album is the way the band plays around with structure. This is perhaps most evident on the schizophrenic ballad "Oh Ana". The song jumps from calm, gentle vocals to loud, frenzied cries begging for Ana to hear them, before returning to the previous state of calm. The song is obviously written about anorexia, although it is unclear who in the band has been touched by the disorder. Unlike many songs written about such issues, the lyrics are very thoughtful and philosophical.
"I'll fake god today
Hop up on a cloud and watch the world decay
Ana on my shoulders and we'll laugh away
Faking this god can't be good for Ana's safety"
Other album highlights include Dirty Town and the wonderfully creative Tic Toc (unrelated to the pop hit of the same name, which I haven't actually heard due to the cultural bubble with which I have surrounded myself).
Then there was O My Heart, released only a year after Touch Up. Through what I can only explain by accusing the band of being wizards, it was just as good as their debut, if not better. This was the album from which Ghosting arose. Since I have already gone into detail about that track, I will spare you from a lengthy rant about how great this album was. I will simply say that there wasn't a single song on it that I thought dropped the ball in any way, and am even working on my own cover of Arms Tonite, despite the curious misspelling.
I would recommend this band to... well, anyone I talk to, really. Mother Mother is one of those bands that I will recommend purely on the basis that I think more people should have heard of them. Check them out. Seriously.